Nopy's Blog

Anime, figures, magazines, and everything related.

Shining Hearts – Bread of Happiness or Happiness of Bread?

April 26, 2012 By: Nopy Category: Anime

I don’t usually watch bread anime (the only one I’ve seen before this was Yakitate!! Japan), but with so-called “slice-of-life” anime *cough* Ano Hana *cough* turning out to be more drama than slice-of-life, I wanted something that could induce at least some yawning. That’s when I heard about Shining Hearts – Shiawase no Pan (Shining Hearts – Bread of Happiness).

Written by Itsuro Kawasaki (Wild Arms: Twilight Venom, Tsubasa Chronicle: Tori Kago no Kuni no Himegimi), Shining Hearts is a dating-sim-turned-anime published by Sega in 2010 and is well-known for its horrific storyline and scenes so cute and sweet that they make your stomach churn. Being a dating sim, it does have some XXX scenes which are essential to the story and if you want to see them, you can watch the uncensored story on Youtube.

The story centers around Rick Elwood, a swordsman that recently lost his family in a fatal storm. He would not have made it either if it weren’t for an experimental baking technique that was performed for him. Unfortunately, the surgery left an unintended side-effect: Rick’s senses are now so warped that people appear to him like cute busty girls dressed in revealing clothing. Buildings, trees, mountains, and even the clouds seem like they might have cute girls hiding amongst them. In this hellish world, Rick’s only ray of hope is the bread he bakes every morning.

Shining Hearts entertains some philosophical questions; what is bread? is baking affected by the ingredients? and can every girl truly have double D’s? If you are the only one that can bake, does that make you a baker, or is the world a baker? Can someone love bread if they’re a male non-lead character that no one can stand? Are pretty elves the evil ones, or should we look within ourselves to find true evil? The answers to these questions may be more terrifying than you can imagine.

The major theme in Shining Hearts is that appearances are never as they seem. Bread and other baked goods are highly contrasted, but at the same time the boundary between them is so blurred that you can’t tell the difference. Rick’s disregard for cute girls is so lamentable that it’ll make anyone sick, but it’s driven by his love for bread and is unconditional love not one of the most beautiful things in the world?

My favourite thing about this story is that almost everything can be interpreted with two opposing views. Is Rick really descending into the abyss of insanity, or is he rising towards enlightenment? Is bread a distraction from all of the beautiful girls on the island, or is it a food seeking love and acceptance? Shining Hearts leaves it up to the viewer to decide.

What makes Shining Hearts stand out among the other “let’s bake bread” stories, is that it is very absorbing. Unlike stories that depend on naked black men to shock the audience, Shining Hearts relies on the audience’s tendency to deny an outcome despite obvious hints. Imagine seeing someone collapse on the sidewalk near a bakery from a tall building. The person appears to be starving, but then someone opens the door to the bakery – a baker is coming. You want to help, you shout and bang on the window and hope that someone comes to save the poor souls. No one comes and all you can do is watch as the person devours all of the innocent bread in the bakery. That’s what Shining Hearts makes you feel – a sense of hopelessness, disbelief, and horror.

I highly recommend Shining Hearts to mature readers seeking a story that questions perceptions and defies morals. Depending on your personal beliefs, you may encounter bread of happiness or the happiness of bread.


Note: I’m just testing something with this post. For a real review, check out Saya no Uta – Beautifully Grotesque or Grotesquely Beautiful?


April 29, 2012: After receiving several comments, judging from their tone, I’m going to assume that most people didn’t catch on. In case you didn’t notice, this was a word-for-word copy and paste of my previous post; it’s a parody with a lot of sarcasm. All I did was stick in the word ‘bread’ everywhere, replaced the names, and changed some other words. I even inserted a link to the original post to make it more obvious. Perhaps I should do this more often, it seems to work well.

Be Sociable, Share!

26 Comments to “Shining Hearts – Bread of Happiness or Happiness of Bread?”

  1. You captured the awfulness of this series perfectly. Great review!

  2. TsukuyomiMagi99 says:

    I tend to be a fan of Tony Takayanagi’s artwork so no matter how bad the story is, I tend to look past it. Also being a moe fan I am not the most objective critic when it comes to things like this. I haven’t met a moe story that was so cute that it was revolting. I guess that’s what happens when you tend to be a Type B otaku. :D

    • I like Tony Taka’s artwork too, that’s why I’m still watching this series. I didn’t want to write a post raving about how good the character designs are though, especially considering how mediocre everything else is.

  3. After three episodes…BREAD?! I mean, I hope the story begins sooner or later…:D
    feal87 recently posted..Kore wa Zombie Desu Ka? Of the dead – Best episode of the season?!

  4. I’ve watched some older “Shining”-Anime and it was yuck. I’m skipping this, reminds me too much of the sacred blacksmith in the way it sounds obsolete :P

    • I’ve seen quite a few Sacred Blacksmith-like anime over the years. Admittedly, I enjoyed them at first because I didn’t know better, but now I expect more from anime.

  5. Oh some sarcasm about the bread bakery anime ^^

    The girls are so cute and innocent in this anime, sugarcoat overload.
    In the first two episodes the story really appeared too happy and calm.
    I hope it will get more interesting in the progress, if not I can at least enjoy the sweet girls, Kaguya for example (>◡<)♡
    Wieselhead recently posted..New Preorders part 12

    • That’s the bright side, even if the story sucks, at least the girls are cute. It would be nice if the story gets more interesting, then it would be worth watching for more people.

  6. Excuse me but I laughed XD
    Kuuki recently posted..What I have learnt from the AniBlog Tourney

  7. I see what you did there… lol

  8. I think the production team is french since they emphasis a LOT on bread and bakery lol
    fabrice recently posted..Holo a Cotignac

  9. Hmmm, well the plot is finally starting up since episode 3, and that’s how it usually works with anime
    Also, Shining Hearts is an RPG game, with an actual fighting system. Not a visual novel, which is what you more than likely confuse to be a dating sim, there’s a very clear difference between them

    • I know it’s not a visual novel or an eroge, but keeping in line with this article being a parody of my previous post, I didn’t want to change too much or else no one would notice.

  10. You sure put a lot of thought into this post, but what exactly are you testing?
    hoshiko recently posted..Aniblog Tourney: Alright, Let’s Do This!

    • I wouldn’t say I put that much thought into it. If you compare this post with my previous one, you’ll see exactly what I did.

  11. Rick~
    Level 1
    Weapon: Bread
    Kai recently posted..Top 10 Most Nostalgic Anime

  12. So, this really was about bread? I would have tough it would be about the game it is adapted from… who knew…
    Miette-chan recently posted..Let us commence with an All-Out Attack! Alter’s Aegis – ART WORKS ver.

  13. I almost going to MAL to add this anime to my list and download it ASAP(I notice the same word, but I think it’s just coincidence), and when I reach the last line…you got me xD

    my first comment here =w=

    • Haha, well if you like bread, then you might end up liking the series. I’m happy to see more people commenting :)


2 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Anti-Social Geniuses Reference Resource Mondays « Organization Anti-Social Geniuses 30 04 12
  2. Aniblog Tourney Round 2 Highlight IX - METANORN 04 05 12

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Affiliates

  • Blog Directory
  • free web stats